This tutorial will talk about the comparison of MakeMKV, DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper vs Brorsoft Blu-ray Ripper in supported Blu-ray types, output formats, ripping speed aspects. After reading you can choose a proper Blu-ray ripper for yourself.
There is more than one way to rip and convert Blu-rays to digital formats that’s compatible with a wide range of devices. If we searching “blu-ray ripper”on Google, more than 553,000 results within a second. In this case, how to find the right and best Blu-ray ripper to rip all the Blu-ray discs to digital formats that can be play on portable devices (iPhone & Android), backup to DLNA / NAS or Streaming by Plex? Let’s keep on reading.
If you are looking for making digital backups of your favorite Blu-ray movies, you can find few better tools like MakeMKV, a freeware video transcoder that is easy to use, and it is now upgraded to support for latest versions of AACS and BD+. If MKV is only choise, MakeMKV won’t let you down. If not, you will probably have to rip Blu-rays twice to get a needed format since MakeMKV only converts Blu-ray to MKV format. If you want MP4, you need to transcode the MKV files to MP4 with Handbrake. This will take much longer for the second conversion even thought ripping Blu-ray discs to MKV is fast with MakeMKV.
DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper
DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper is a popular shareware to rip 2D and 3D Blu-rays to various videos in specific formats for playback on various devices. While this Blu-ray ripping tool has some disadvantage features:
a.Not support for some commerical Blu-rays: Though DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper supports removing Blu-ray region code A/B/C, Blu-ray encryption technology changes constantly, which is the main fact that causes Blu-ray ripping issues in many ripper tools, and DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper is no exception. Worse still, DVDFab removed decryption functionality from their software and lack of DVD ripping feature.
b.Complex operation: For some users, though there are instructions from DVDFab tech support, for the one who are not-so-tech savvy user, he or she will view all potential Blu-ray ripping issue as a hassle if the interface is not so flexible.
c. Low Mac incompatibility: After testing, we found DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper not working on the latest Mac OS X like macOS Sierra quite well.
d. Limited output formats/devices supported: As is known to all, DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper is able to rip Blu-ray to various formats like MKV, MP4, AVI, MPG, MP3, AAC, etc. However, DVDFab will not allow users to search for a desired output format/device. This is also a big argument against using it.
e. Lack of Blu-ray Copy funtions: DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper supports ripping Blu-ray to various formats but unfortunately, 1:1 copying BLu-ray and making main titile Blu-ray functions not added to DVDFab Blu-ray Copy.
f. Slow Ripping speed: It is a little disappointing when it comes to the time it takes to rip a Blu-ray since it does not support AMD APP encoding. Many times the Blu-ray ripping conversion with DVDFab is lagging behind other Blu-ray rippers.
g. High price: It costs $60 per year which is too expensive than its alternatives.
Conlusion: DVDFab Blu-ray Riper is quite limited as well. But it is provide copy Blu-ray to any blank Blu-ray/DVD/AVCHD disc.
Brorsoft Blu-ray Ripper
Brorsoft Blu-ray Ripper is able to do all MakeMKV and DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper can do for ripping Blu-rays and DVDs.
|* Support any kinds of Blu-ray & DVD movies
* Convert fast while keeping excellent video quality
* Rip Blu-ray/DVD to any popular format with ease
* Provide 150+ video presets for iPad, Apple TV, Android and more
* Backup your Blu-ray and DVD movies with 1:1 orginal quality
* Edit and personalize DVD/Blu-ray instantly
* Support H.265/HEVC output video format
* Support batch conversion
|Supported OS:||Windows10 – Windows XP||Windows 10 vs macOS Sierra|
|macOS Sierra, Mac OS X 10.11 – 10.5|
Please turn to Brorsoft Blu-ray Ripper Page for full features.
A simply comparison chart here:
|SOFTWARE||MAKEMKV||Brorsoft Blu-ray Ripper||DVDFAB|
|Rip encrypted or copy-protected DVD|
|Blu-ray Disc/BDMV Folder/ISO Image|
|DVD Disc/Video_TS Folder/IFO/ISO Image|
|Convert DVD to all populat video/audio format|
|Rip DVD to MKV|
|Rip DVD to MP4|
|Rip DVD to AVI|
|Rip DVD to WMV|
|Rip DVD to MOV|
|Rip DVD to H.265|
|Rip DVD to VOB, FLV, AVI, WMV, MP4, 3GP, MPEG, MP3, M4A, AIFF, AC3, WAV, and more.|
|Provide ready presets for different devices|
|Stream DVD movies to iPhone, iPad, Samsung Galaxy Tab, HTC and many other devices supported video format, ready presets are provided.|
|Well compatible with Mac OS X|
|Works well on macOS Sierra and Mac OS X ( 10.11-10.5)|
|Advanced parameter setting|
|You can adjust the output video/audio parameters like frame rate, bit rate, etc. to fit batter with you needs.|
|Advanced parameter setting|
|Split or merge DVD movies, change video visual effects, customize brightness, saturation, volume, add watermarks, subtitles and so forth.|
|Retrieve DVD movies information|
|Easy access for uses to retrieve and embed DVD movie metadata infomation, which includes movie description, director, editor, release date, genre and more.|
|Directly add files to itunes Library after conversion|
|You can add all converted files to iTunes Library afterconversion.|
|Supports ripping multiple files at a time.|
|1:1 Full Disc Copy|
|Main Movie Copy|
|Select Desired Internal Subtitle Language|
|Enable Force Subtitle Option|
|Add External SRT/ASS/SSA Subtitle|
|Keep 5.1 Dolby Digtial Audio|
|Keep 7.1 Dolby Digtial Plus or DTS Audio|
|Video Editing Features (trim/crop/merge/split/crop/watermark/effect)|
|= supported = unsupported = unknow|
Brorsoft Blu-ray Ripper (Windows | Mac) – Price:
$55.95 $35.95, is more powerful than MakeMKV, DVDFab Blu-ray Ripper. It can perfectly rip Blu-ray to any digital files and create backups of Blu-rays with two ways (entire disc copy and directly main title copy). If you have Blu-rays, no matter for wide streaming or just disc protection, Brorsoft Blu-ray Ripper can help you finish all the tasks.